From: GF Haddad <Qasyoun@cyberia.net.lb>
To: MSA-EC <firstname.lastname@example.org>
Subject:8:02 PM 7/1/99 Re: Ala Hazrat Imam Ahmed Raza Khan  False ALLEGATIONS by WAHABIS !
Date: Sunday, May 23, 1999 2:57 PM
MSA-EC - http://sunnah.org
Salam alaykum, concerning the following remarks:
>thanawi accepted the compliments by his mureed that he was a rasul; he
>insulted Rasul; khaleel said that shayTaan knew more
>than Rasul; gangohi said that Allah could lie; nanothvi said that a
>prophet can appear; ismayil dahalwi made atrocious remarks
>on Rasul and awlia if the shari`ah compels him to make takfeer, he as a
>mufti should. incidentally, these handful are
>everyone to the blind-followers of the dobs.
I must say I have not seen clarity or reliable precision in this series of
posts, or even basic adab with the scholars of Islam.
All of the above allegations have to be very carefully and in conscience
double-checked in the light of evidence and according to the procedure of
Shari`a. At the very least one should quote the exact words of the
authority or authorities who leveled those charges against these scholars,
as well as the latter's exact original expressions under dispute, if they
exist or if one has real knowledge of them.
To say: "he who doubts in their kufr (deobandis) is also a kaafir" is
completely rejected. Ya hu, Dar al-`Ulum in Deoband is an Islamic
university whose curriculum consists entirely in the mothers of books in
Sunni `aqida, usul, and fiqh, and which has produced the greatest fuqaha'
and hadith scholars of India since its inception. Are you throwing all
these, their students (past and present), us, and the general public who
has no idea of these divergences into the Fire with a few casual words?
Even if this condemnation did not apply to Deobandis, it is still
unacceptable to say: "he who doubts in the kufr of X is also a kaafir"
except in very, very clearcut cases such as idolatry -- we seek refuge in
Allah. Even then, there is a difference between the kufr of X in saying a
particular statement tantamount to kufr, and his being a kafir. There is a
great difference. What about those who are unclear about it for various
reasons, such as not ascertaining the exact meaning of X's words? Are we
going to be like Abu al-`Ala' al-Bukhari who declared: "he who doubts in
the kufr of Ibn `Arabi is also a kafir, and he who calls Ibn Taymiyya
Shaykh al-Islam is a kafir"? Is it not better to be like Mulla `Ali
al-Qari who said that in such cases the best course is silence?
The rule is: "We do not declare as disbelievers any of the People of the
Qibla other than upon denial of a mass-transmitted article of Islamic
The Prophet -- Allah bless and greet him -- called Mu`adh a rasul. Shaytan
knows more unbeneficial knowledge than anyone else, including the
Prophets. Allah said -- in meaning -- "And they schemed, and Allah
schemed, and Allah is the best of schemers." That is, He throws back the
lies of liars upon them in their own terms. And Allah knows best what the
above-named scholars meant in their original remarks.
What I know about the scholars of India listed above and below is that
they are pure Sunnis. They defended tawassul and refuted Salafi
innovations on the matter of ziyara of the Prophet -- Allah bless and
- `Allama muhaddith Rashid Ahmad al-Gangohi (d. 1905 CE)
- `Allama muhaddith Khalil Ahmad al-Saharanfuri (d. 1927 CE)
- `Allama muhaddith Shaykh Mahmud al-Hasan al-Deobandi
- `Allama shaykh Mir Ahmad Hasan al-Husayni
- `Allama muhaddith shaykh `Aziz al-Rahman al-Deobandi
- `Allama murshid shaykh `Ali Ashraf al-Tahanawi
- `Allama shaykh Shah `Abd al-Rahim al-Ranfuri
- Shaykh al-Hajj al-Hakim Muhammad Hasan al-Deobandi
- Mawlawi Qudrat Allah
- Mawlawi mufti Kifayat Allah
- `Allama shaykh Muhammad Yahya Saharanfuri
Their anti-Salafi fatwa on ziyara is available at www.sunnah.org if I
As for Abu al-Qasim Nanotwi, it is enough credit for him that he stood
firmly in the face of the Ahmadiyya heresy.
As for `Abd al-Hayy al-Lucknawi (d. 1304) who apparently was insulted in
another post, he and Ahmad Zufar al-Tahanawi (d. 1393) are the greatest
hadith scholars that India has known in the last hundred years, and this
Sunni Muslim is definitely innocent of anyone who attacks them. `Abd
al-Hayy on ziyara alone wrote three long fatwas in refutation of Ibn
>said ashraf `ali thanawi listing matters of kufr and shirk in his book
>to do meelad ash-sharif, to visit the graves, to seek help from them etc,
>are all shirk.
I do not remember reading the above in my English Bashishti Zewar and I
doubt that Ashraf `Ali al-Tahanawi said that to celebrate mawlid or visit
the graves is shirk. As for seeking help apart from Allah it is shirk
whether from the living or the dead.
Ashraf `Ali al-Tahanawi wrote a treatise entitled "Nayl al-Shifa' bi Na`l
al-Mustafa" (Obtaining remedy through the sandals of the Elect One) found
in his book Zad al-Sa`id (Provision for the fortunate). The muhaddith of
India Shaykh Muhammad Zakariyya Kandihlawi said in his English translation
of al-Tirmidhi's Shama'il:
"Maulana Ashraf `Ali Thanwi Sahib has written in his book Zaadus Sa`eed a
detailed treatise on the barakat and virtues of the shoes of Rasulullah
Sallallahu `Alayhi Wasallam. Those interested in this should read that
book (which is available in English). In short, it may be said that it
[the Prophet's sandal] has countless qualities. The `ulama have
experienced it many a time. One is blessed by seeing Rasulullah Sallallahu
`Alayhi Wasallam in one's dreams; one gains safety from oppressors and
every heartfelt desire is attained. Every object is fulfilled by its
tawassul (means, petition, request). The method of tawassul is also
In his book Nashr al-tib (in Urdu, p. 6 and 215 of the Lahore edition) the
same Ashraf Ali Thanwi cites among his evidence the hadith of Jabir: "The
first thing that Allah created is the light of the Prophet, Allah bless
and greet him" on the authority of `Abd al-Razzaq, and relies upon it.
Does all this strike the Sunni Muslim as the custom of one who condemns
Mawlid or tawassul through the Prophet and awliya? La hawla wa la quwwata
May Allah have mercy on all of them, and may Allah teach us to realize the
position of the ulamas of this Community in His presence.
To unsubscribe, write to email@example.com
Start Your Own FREE Email List at http://www.listbot.com/